Paul M. Jones

Don't listen to the crowd, they say "jump."

ASP-Style Programming in PHP?

An old buddy of mine wants to start using PHP, but the problem is that he's been working with Microsoft technologies for so long, he doesn't get "the PHP way". His background, for many years, has been with ASP.NET, COM, and those sorts of things.

As it turns out, there's a PHP framework out there that maps well to "the ASP.NET way": Prado.

http://www.pradosoft.com/

They're at a 3.0 release as of a week ago, and won the Zend PHP5 competition last year, so that should speak to the quality of the software. From the page about PRADO we can see they base their concepts on a component model, so it's very like Apache Tapestry, Borland Delphi, and (for the guy who asked me originally) Microsoft ASP:

Most PHP frameworks are trying to establish a loose standard of organizing PHP programming, most preferably the MVC (model-view-controller) model. It is difficult to compare PRADO with these frameworks because they have different focuses. What we can say is, PRADO is more like a high-level language built upon PHP while those MVC frameworks stand for the best programming practices. Both aim to help developers to rapidly complete Web application development. The advantage of PRADO is its rich set of prebuilt powerful components and extreme reusability of the PRADO code, while the advantage of the MVC frameworks is the complete separation of model, view and controller, which greatly facilitates team integration.

I can see that PRADO is very much *not* my style; I don't know a lot of open-source scripter types (Perl/PHP/Python/Ruby) who would really go for this, as it seems over-architected to me. This is not meant as a critical point against PRADO, because it obviously fills the needs for those who like that style of programming. Personally, I don't really want another language on top of PHP (this relates back to why I started Savant; i.e., as a response to Smarty). But if you're used to Microsoft or Java, I can see how this would be an easy way to get on board in the open-source world and start using PHP with your previous non-PHP habits.

Which brings me to a philosophical point: is there a better phrase than "the PHP way" to describe the way we expect PHP apps to be built, or some sort of metaphor that encapsulates the concepts related to "the PHP way"? Not just MVC, because PRADO appears to do that, but some other way of describing succinctly how a PHP app "ought" to be. Maybe there isn't one single description.

Having said that, I think these template notes from the WACT project might be useful hints; see also here. My bet is that the greater majority of PHP/Perl/Python/Ruby programmers are "imperative" guys than "declarative" guys, and maybe that plays into what a proper metaphor might be. Prado/ASP.NET are clearly more declarative, and Savant/Solar/etc are clearly more imperative. Perhaps Less Code is related to the metaphor we want.

I'd be interested to hear comments and feedback, if for no other reason than to compare and contrast the different approaches.

UPDATE (2006-05-04): Interesting analysis from here; note that it is originally from Dec 2005.


Instant Forms from Tables with Solar

I was talking with Matthew this morning, and he asked if I was setting up a methodology to create forms using table definitions. My answer was "yes!".

Here's an example: 2 lines to start Solar, 2 lines to connect to an existing Solar_Sql_Table, 2 lines to create a Solar_Form using the table columns, and 2 lines to display it with Solar_View using the associated form helper. (The "Solar_Model_Nodes" table is part of the existing Solar_Content domain model.)

<?php
// prelims
require 'Solar.php';
Solar::start();

// sql and table connection
Solar::register('sql', 'Solar_Sql');
$table = Solar::factory('Solar_Model_Nodes');

// get a form and load elements from the table
$form = Solar::factory('Solar_Form');
$form->load('Solar_Form_Load_Table', $table);

// display the form
$view = Solar::factory('Solar_View');
echo $view->form($form);

// done!
Solar::stop();
?>

This creates an element for each column and a form-level validation based on the column datatype. Number and string columns get a properly-sized "text" element, CLOBs get a "textarea", and booleans get a checkbox. If the column has its own validation of "inList" or "inKeys", it gets a "select" element of the allowed values. Soon, when I add Ajax-y widgets, date/time/timestamp columns will get date-picker elements.

The $form->load() call can use 'Solar_Form_Load_Xml' too, if you want to define forms using XML. (I don't, but Matthew liked the idea and contributed the code.)

If you only want certain columns, you can pass a list of them as the third param to $form->load():

$cols = array('email', 'subj', 'body');
$form->load('Solar_Form_Load_Table', $table, $cols);

Now, this is not all sweetness and light; the magic requires that you do the work of definining your columns in the Solar_Sql_Table class. Lucky for us, that's pretty easy. More on that in another post.


Solar 0.17.0 Released

This release of Solar includes a minor BC break in how Solar_Sql_Table lets you set up column validation. It also standardizes how validation routines get feedback messages. The change notes are:

* Solar_Sql_Table

    * When specifying a 'valid' key for a column, you now get only
      one validation; if you need more than one validation routine,
      use the 'multiple' method.  Also, you can now specify the
      validation message key you want to use, instead of it being
      forced to 'VALID_COLNAME' (where COLNAME is the column name).
      You can still use a string as the 'valid' key value for simple
      validations.  These changes per discussion with Jeff Surgeson.

    * Uses more Solar_Valid validations internally now

* Solar_Form_Load_Table

    * Modified loading logic to use the new Solar_Sql_Table::$_col
      'valid' key value structure.

* Solar_Valid

    * New method feedback() standardizes Solar_Sql_Table and Solar_Form
      calls where a validation message is returned when data validation
      fails; this is the opposite of all other Solar_Valid methods, in
      that an empty return value indicated success, not failure.

    * New method range() checks a value against min and max range

    * New method rangeLength() checks the length of a value against
      min and max lengths

    * Renamed method inScope() to scope()

Automating Release Tasks

I noted earlier today that I've made 5 releases of Solar in 7 days. (Clearly I'm a fan of "release early, release often." ;-) Obviously, I have the Solar-talk subscribers to thank for pointing out bugs and and making functionality requests; these are what drive the need for a release ... thanks, guys. :-)

But what I want to talk about in this entry is the release process itself. With the help of Greg Beaver (indirectly) and Clay Loveless (directly), Solar now has a moderate-length PHP script that handles almost all aspects of the release process automatically. Usage is at the command line; issue "php release.php" for a test run, or "php release.php commit" for a full release-and-commit cycle.

With any luck, the lessons I've learned here will be of use to someone else; with more luck, perhaps someone else will see possible improvements and mention them here. Read on for a narrative of how the script came to be.

First Iteration

The first person I have to thank here is Greg Beaver and his great work on the PEAR packaging and installation tools. Without his stewardship and maintenenance of this wonderful toolset, the Solar release process would be much more difficult than it is.

Even with the PEAR installer, though, building a package XML release file by hand is a terribly tedious exercise. So the second person I have to thank is Clay Loveless: some months ago, he wrote up the first iteration of the auto-packager for Solar using PEAR_PackageFileManager. I added on a bit to it at that time so that we could keep release information (authors, change notes, etc) in a separate location.

The point of keeping the relase info in a separate location was so we could avoid having to modify the packaging script for every release. The script looks for an "info/" directory; in that directory, there is a sub-directory for every release number, and contained therein are a number text and comma-separated values files. The packaging script then uses those files to generate the "header" portions of the PEAR pacakge file. You can see an example "info/" directory here.

Second Iteration

The PEAR_PackageFileManager has a great auto-replacement utility built in. It can look through the source code at installationpackage time and replace certain keywords, such as "@package_version@", with the proper value for that particular installation. (UPDATE: [19:33 CST] Greg Beaver pointed out that addGlobalReplacement() does replace at package-time. Once again, Greg proves he has thought of all the right things. Thanks man.)

But there's a small problem with that for non-PEAR users. Because the replacements happen at installation-time, not at package-time, it means the pearball still has the keywords in place, not the actual values. For methods like Solar::apiVersion() which depend on the automated replacement of "@pacakge_version@" with the correct version number, this is a functionality break for them.

It turns out there's an easy, if somewhat brute-force, solution: copy the original source to a temporary location, replace keywords yourself, and then have PEAR package that new codebase with the keywords pre-replaced. You can see this portion of the code in release.php at the comment noted "prepare package directory".

We copy the original source ("src/") to a packaging directory ("pkg/") and str_replace() keywords in the new "pkg/" directory. When PEAR_PackageFileManager comes into play, it works on the "pkg/" directory instead of the original source. Note also that the pre-replacements happen in documentation files as well (more on that in a bit).

The end result of this is a pearball/tarball that is equally useful to PEAR and non-PEAR installation processes.

Third (and Current) Iteration

So that takes care of the packaging itself. The last issues to handle are mostly administrative. On a full commit cycle, we need to check a few things before rolling the release:

  • Set Subversion keywords on all files
  • Update the wiki files in "docs/apiref/" (these are built with a custom class that applies the PHP5 Reflection API to each class in Solar; more on that in another post)
  • Make sure all pending changes have been committed to Subversion

If those pre-flight checks pass, we then need to actually build the package (see iterations 1 and 2 above). After that:

  • Tag the release using "svn copy"
  • Commit the tagged release to Subversion
  • Extract the documentation files for updating the Solar website

The release.php script splits this into three task sets.

First, the administrative tasks are handled at the top of the script under "status check". This sets keywords, builds docs, etc., and then makes sure that there weren't any changes as a result. If these automated tasks generated changes (as noted by "svn status" returning any ouput at all), the script terminates with a warning to handle outstanding issues.

Second, after the package is built, near the end of the script, we issue a series of "svn" commands to tag the release and commit to the repository.

Finally, we unzip a copy of the pearball and pull out a copy of the docs; these are re-zipped in a separate tarball for upload to the Solar site. We use the packaged docs instead of the source docs so we don't get all the .svn files mixed in with them.

Manual Tasks

There are still some manual tasks to accomplish in a release, but they're easy: upload the pearball to the channel server, upload the docs to the website ... oh, and write an entry about the release on my blog. ;-)


Solar 0.16.1 released

This is a minor bugfix and enhancement release to the Solar library and framework for PHP5. The biggest changes are:

  • Packaging script now properly keeps Solar/App/Public in the main
    library directory (instead of in the data directory) ... reported
    by StR.
  • Solar_View_Helper_Form now uses a 'text' element when an
    unrecognized element type is requested
  • Solar_Controller_Page::_forward() now sets $this->_view properly (previously, was
    not replacing dashes with slashes)

Let's see, that's 5 releases in 7 days; not too shabby. I think it's time to blog about the release process.


Solar 0.16.0 released

Version 0.16.0 of the simple object library and application repository for PHP5 was released yesterday, mostly because I needed to make a minor schema change to one of the "content" tables. Seems the word "position" is reserved in some databases, and I was using that as a column name; the migration script in this release renames it to "pos". There are other minor changes to the Solar_Sql class as well (including more documentation :-).


Solar 0.15.2 released

Just a quick note: fixed two bugs (one in the Solar_Controller_Page::_redirect() method, and one in Solar_App_Bookmarks "user" action for RSS feeds) and released 0.15.2, available now.

Solar is a simple object library and application repository for PHP. It acts as a framework for application development in PHP5, and runs cleanly under E_ALL | E_STRICT error reporting levels.


Solar 0.15.0 alpha released

Yesterday, I uploaded the first non-development (!) release of Solar, version 0.15.0 alpha. I know, "alpha" is only slightly less change-prone than "devel", but it's a move forward and it makes me happy. :-)

You can see the change notes here, but the major updates are:

  • Solar_Uri has been refactored to be much easier to use, from 16 methods down to 5, with better "action" and "public" support, and it works with mod_rewrite now. (N.b.: Jeff Surgeson noted an issue earlier today with non-mod_rewrite subdirectories, but I've committed a fix and will roll 0.15.1 later today.)
  • Solar_User_Auth now calls session_regenerate_id() on all status changes, and calls to session_start() are no longer silenced.
  • Solar_Filter method names have been made consistent with each other.

Speaking of Solar_Filter, it probably bears comparison with Zend_Filter and Zend_InputFilter, seeing as they were recently reviewed at SitePoint. Solar actually has two separate classes for these functions: Solar_Valid, to check if input matches a particular format, and Solar_Filter, to force input to match a particular format. (Solar_Filter was contributed by Matthew Weier O'Phinney some months ago; thanks, Matthew.)

After Solar 0.15.1 has been out the door a couple more days, I'll be ready to start *adding* functionality instead of adjusting (and breaking, and re-fixing ;-) existing functionality. High on the list of new functions will be:

  • a Solar_User_Access class for standardized application-level access control,
  • integration of the Dojo Toolkit for animations and effects (especially on forms),
  • and a new Solar_App_Todo application (for to-do lists, obviously).

I'll be adding more narrative documentation, and perhaps start blogging about usage, as part of future efforts as well.

UPDATE (12:25 CST) -- Just released Solar 0.15.1 with the subdirectory/mod_rewrite fix.


Solar 0.14.0 Released

Second release in two days! Amazing how "employed" I am, after having quit Zend. ;-)

Solar is a simple object library and application repository for PHP5. It is framework-and-library for web-application development, with an emphasis on distribution, localization, and database portability. You can download it via a PEAR channel and browse the Subversion repository.

Here are some highlights from the change notes:

  • The PEAR installer is still the recommended means of installing and upgrading Solar, but it is no longer required. You can now download the pearball directly, place the files manually, and they'll work just fine.
  • Solar/Layouts has moved to Solar/App/Layouts.
  • There are no more app-specific Public/ directories; instead, all public resources for Solar apps are in Solar/App/Public/, and are broken down by images/, scripts/, and styles/.
  • Solar_Filter has more methods, and the names have changed (see the change notes for full details).
  • Solar_Valid has changed some method names (see the change notes for full details)
  • Solar_Controller_Front::_setup() no longer registers sql, user, and content objects; these registrations have been moved down to the Solar_App page controller to lazy-load them as late as possible.

Of particular note, the Solar_Form form processor, and the related Solar_View_Helper_Form class, combined with the new default.css file, now highlight the feedback messages differently based on the form status (i.e., validation "success" or "failure").

I have also updated the solarphp.com site with the new documentation, and the new doc-reading infrastructure. It's mostly technical API documentation, but there are some actual tutorial pieces in place. Also, for now, this means no more user-comments on the site, but I'll keep the existing ones and put them back once I build a new commenting app.

The next major tasks are to refine the Solar_Sql_Select column deconfliction logic, and/or add Solar_Sql_TableRow and _TableRowset classes, perhaps to replace Solar_Sql_Result.

After that, I'll be ready to move Solar out of "development" to an alpha or even beta status. That will be a happy day. :-)


Solar 0.13.0 Released

Solar is a simple object library and application repository for PHP5. It is framework-and-library for web-application development, with an emphasis on distribution, localization, and database portability. You can download it via a PEAR channel and browse the Subversion repository.

The rest of this entry is taken from the migration notes; be sure the read the change log for full details.

Config Key Changes

I've tried to make config keys consistent and standard across all classes. In particular, note these changes:

  • Keys related to username values now use 'handle' (vs 'username')
  • Keys related to password values now use 'passwd' (vs 'password')
  • Keys related to form submission values now use 'submit' (vs 'op')
  • Keys indicating the name of a driver class are now 'driver' (vs 'class')
  • Keys indicating the configuration array for a driver class are now 'config' (vs 'options')

In particular, these config key changes affect Solar_Sql and Solar_User_*.

You should make sure to change your Solar.config.php array to reflect the new keys; e.g., $config['Solar_Sql']['class'] should become $config['Solar_Sql']['driver'].

Also, you should make sure your authentication forms use the new 'handle

Locale Key Changes

Similarly, I've tried to make locale keys consistent and standard across all classes.

  • 'ERR_*' keys are now reserved for exception and error messages, instead of generic feedback (such as form processing).
  • 'SUBMIT_*' keys take the place of earlier 'OP_*' keys, to indicate a form submission value, or a sub-action value (like 'next' or 'previous')
  • New 'SUCCESS_*' and 'FAILURE_*' keys are for non-exception non-error user feedback, such as in form processing
  • Label keys now use '_SUBMIT', '_HANDLE', and '_PASSWD' in relation to the standard config keys for submissions, usernames, and passwords.

Solar_Filter and Solar_Valid

These classes are no longer static; you have to instantiate them. Also, the custom() methods have been renamed to callback() to more clearly indicate how they work.

URI Generation

The Solar_Uri class has two new config keys, 'action' and 'public', to indicate the base href values for actions and public files.

For example, if your front-controller is at '/~username/solar/front.php', set that as your 'action' config key value. Then, all calls to exportAction() will be prefixed with that value. Similarly, if all your public files (CSS, JavaScript, etc) are at '/~username/public', set that as your 'public' config key value, and all calls to exportPublic() will be prefixed with that value.

These keys make it easy to set defaults that will be used throughout Solar, e.g. in Solar_View helpers for action() and publicHref().

View Processing

Solar_View takes the place of Solar_Template, and is a new "flavor" of Savant3 specifically for Solar integration.

There are new helpers as well, in particular the above-mentioned action() and publicHref() for URI generation, as well as new form and form-element helpers with built-in localization using Solar::locale().

When changing your Solar_Template scripts to Solar_View, note that these changes are needed:

  • Solar_Template => Solar_View
  • $tpl->addPath('template', ...) => $view->addTemplatePath(...)
  • $tpl->addPath('resource', ...) => $view->addHelperPath(...)
  • $this->eprint() => echo $this->escape()
  • $this->locale() => $this->getText() || $this->getTextRaw()
  • $this->eprint($this->locale(...)) => echo $this->getText(...)
  • $this->actionLink() => $this->action()
  • $this->ahref() => $this->anchor()
  • $this->form() is completely different; review the Solar_View_Helper_Form documentation to see all the changes. I'll write more about this later.

Front-Controller

The front controller is much lighter now. All layout processing has been moved into the page controller. Also, the way the front controller maps page requests to page classes has been changed. Previously, you would set up an "_app_class" array that mapped short page names to full class names:

<?php
    $_app_class = array(
        'bookmarks' => 'Solar_App_Bookmarks',
        'hello'     => 'Solar_App_Hello',
        'other'     => 'Vendor_App_Other',
    );
?>

In the spirit of auto-discovery, override, and fallback, the front-controller now uses a simpler array of base class names; the short-page name is appended to the class name to get the proper class.

<?php
    $_classes = array(
        'Solar_App',
        'Vendor_Pages',
        'Another_Vendor_App',
    );
?>

If the front-controller receives a request for the page 'hello', it looks first for 'Another_Vendor_App_Hello', then falls back to 'Vendor_Pages_Hello', and finally defaults to 'Solar_App_Hello'.

This allows you to have your own vendor-specific versions of Solar applications. It also means you don't need to add to the map every time you add a new page controller class; just put your app in one of the noted class directories, and the front-controller will find it automatically.

Page Controller

Conversely, the page-controller has become somewhat more robust. It now handles layout processing by reusing the internal view object, which means that all page-level variables are now available to the layout.

In addition, all Solar_App_* classes extend the new Solar_App class, which provides a series of variables specifically for the layout (e.g., $layout_title, $layout_links, etc).

The technique for indicating what variables should be mapped from the URI into the $_info array has changed. Previously, you would key on the action, and provide an array of variable names:

<?php
    $_action_info = array(
        'read' => array('area', 'page');
    )
?>

This would map a URI of "read/Main/HomePage" to the "list" action, and populate $_info['area'] and $_info['page'].

The problem here is that you couldn't tell the page-controller how to map default action variables. E.g., if $_action_default is 'read', then the URI 'Main/HomePage' should map to the 'read' action, but instead it would map to the 'Main' action (which probably doesn't exist).

The new page-controller code uses this format for mapping variables ...

<?php
    $_action_info = array(
        'read' => 'area/page',
    );
?>

... and *does* map variables using the default action_info map, so that calls to non-existent actions map properly. Thus, the 'Main/HomePage' URI will map to the 'read' action and populate the 'area' and 'page' $_info keys for you. This should help make your URIs prettier.

Setting default values for info mapping is easier too; for example:

<?php
    $_action_info = array(
        'read' => 'area=Main/page=HomePage',
    );
?>

Public Directories

The Solar/Layout and the Solar/App classes now have a Public/ directory. These are for storing stylesheets, JavaScript files, images, etc. The problem is that, because Solar is outside the webroot, you need to be able to put these files in a place accessible via http.

There are two ways to do this; either way, you need to create a 'public/Solar' directory in your web root. Then in that location, either:

  • Create a symbolic link to the related Solar "Public/" directories, or
  • Copy the related Solar "Public/" directories

The main drawback is that you need to link to (or copy) each Public/ directory; each new app means a new link. I'm going to try to find some way of either collecting all Public/ resources in one logical place, or automating the linking/copying process as part of the installation process.

Next Tasks

I need to update the site itself with the new documentation. After that, I will...

  • Revisit Solar_Filter and Solar_Valid to standardize the method names
  • Make Solar_Sql_Select a "fluent" class

After that, I think I'm going to be able to call the current codebase relatively stable; not release-candidate quality, but certainly preview-release or beta-level.

Of course I need to continue writing documentation and tests, but since this release should be the last major shakeup for a long time, docs should be easier to build and longer-lasting.